Differences between seltzer, club soda, and tonic water
Mindfulness of your diet should include the drink choices you make. Carbonated water has become a popular option for many. It’s hydrating and has a light and satisfying taste. While carbonated soda and seltzer provide healthier alternatives to sweetened soft drinks, there are some major differences. Does seltzer water taste better than club soda? Which carbonated drink delivers the most health benefits?
With several types of carbonated water on the market, these are just some of the many questions you may be asking yourself. If you wonder about their similarities and differences, keep reading to find out whether you should add seltzer or carbonated soda to your cart next time you head to the grocery store.
There’s almost no visual difference between seltzer, club soda, and tonic water when poured in glasses side by side, but a few key differences set them apart. People seeking healthier lifestyles have turned to carbonated water for a few reasons. It’s an excellent substitute for soft or sweetened drinks. Club soda, seltzer, and tonic water are both hydrating and fizzy. The varying processes and methods that each beverage goes through and the added compounds often result in different flavors, which is why some people prefer one type of drink over another. If you want to learn the differences between carbonated waters, here’s a helpful guide that can assist you in telling the differences.
Club Soda
Club Soda is injected with carbon dioxide gas or CO2. It contains added minerals like potassium sulfate, sodium chloride, and sodium bicarbonate. Depending on the manufacturer, each club soda's mineral content may vary. This beverage tastes like seltzer water but is often slightly saltier. Despite this, club soda has a clean, fresh taste that mixes well with your favorite alcoholic beverage. Club soda can also be used in non-alcoholic lemonades and Italian sodas. The sodium content in club soda will also vary based on serving size and brand. If you are in good health and consume club soda in moderation, you shouldn’t worry about excessive sodium intake.
Seltzer
Carbonated artificially with carbon dioxide, seltzer water doesn’t contain added minerals and has a plainer taste than club soda. It has zero calories and no sugar making it an excellent substitute for soda and sweetened juices. Seltzer water is sold plain or infused with natural flavors like citrus. It is great when mixed with vodka or as a base for other beverages like sodas. Be careful: some manufacturers also add artificial sweeteners to their seltzers, trying to find a niche between seltzer waters and diet sodas. These sweeteners alter the flavor profile, the possible uses for the drink, and they add health considerations for some.
Tonic Water
Tonic water is the only carbonated water on this list that contains high-fructose corn syrup, and like club soda, tonic water contains added minerals. Unlike seltzer or club soda, this beverage is more soda than water. Because it’s sweetened with sugar, it is also the only carbonated water on this list that contains calories. Flavored with quinine, it has a bitter and somewhat sweet flavor that pairs well as a mixer for cocktails with gin or vodka. This drink is the least likely to be drunk alone, and most people opt for a bottle of club soda or sparkling mineral water instead.
Is seltzer or club soda healthier?
Both club soda and seltzer water provide great options for hydrating and boast similar nutritional health benefits. Additionally, these drinks can help you meet your daily water needs if you struggle to stay hydrated with just plain water. One key point stands out when comparing the nutritional value of seltzer water to club soda: sodium. If you’re a big fan of carbonated drinks but find yourself opting for club soda over seltzer, you may want to consider switching to reduce your sodium intake.
If you’re dealing with high blood pressure or cardiovascular health issues, seltzer water is an excellent option for drinking regularly. Enjoying a club soda from time to time won’t affect you tremendously, but if you drink upwards of three a day, it will significantly add to your sodium intake. Products that contain added sugar or carbohydrates can negatively impact your health, and you should do your best to stick to plain club soda or seltzer water. Some people find that the carbonation in both soothes upset stomachs. Choosing which one to drink is a matter of preference because both deliver similar benefits to your health.
You should be mindful of drinking seltzer water or other carbonated beverages when you exercise. While these drinks are just as hydrating as water, the added carbonation may cause bloating or cramps during vigorous activity. If you consume a lot of acidic fruit like pineapples, grapefruits, and pomegranate or have a highly acidic diet try to cut back on seltzer. The carbonation might cause issues for those who struggle with conditions like IBS or a sensitive gastrointestinal system. While carbonated drinks may help address symptoms of a temporarily upset stomach, people who suffer from chronic digestive issues might want to generally steer clear of carbonated drinks.
Enhance the flavor of your carbonated drink
Many prefer sweetened sodas and juices to plain water with meals or throughout the day. Drinking these beverages regularly can lead to tooth decay and health issues like kidney damage and elevated blood pressure. If you can’t seem to get enough water in during the day and carbonated water is not doing the trick, consider improving the flavor of seltzer water or club soda naturally. You can squeeze fresh lemon or orange into seltzer water or club soda and get a natural energy boost from the natural sugars.
Putting berries or citrus fruits into a glass water bottle infuses the water with delicious flavors and adds antioxidants that can give your immune system some extra support. Adding fresh mint leaves to a glass of ice water is refreshing on a hot summer’s day, and you can choose to enjoy it with plain or seltzer water. Drinking plenty of water throughout the day can help you reach your fitness goals and is ideal for optimal health. Before purchasing seltzer water or club soda from the grocery store, you’ll want to check the ingredients and make sure they don’t contain unwanted additives or calories. Plain carbonated drinks are a healthier alternative to sugary sodas and juices that can have a significant and long-lasting impact on your health.
QUESTION
According to the USDA, there is no difference between a “portion” and a “serving.” See AnswerHealth Solutions From Our Sponsors
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention: "Get the Facts: Sugar-Sweetened Beverages and Consumption."
Cleveland Clinic: "How Healthy is Sparkling or Mineral Water?"
Cleveland Clinic: "Is Sparkling Water Good for You?"
The New York Times: "Is Carbonated Water Just as Healthy as Still Water?"
UChicago Medicine: "Are sparkling water and hard seltzer bad for you?"
UW Medicine: "Is Sparkling Water Bad For You?"
Top Which is Healthier Seltzer or Club Soda Related Articles
Can Drinking Water Help Prevent a Stroke?
Many studies have proven that proper hydration at the time of a stroke is linked to better stroke recovery. It is possible that dehydration causes blood to be thicker. Viscous blood causes the body to retain sodium and increases blood pressure. Drinking enough water regularly prevents dehydration. This may play a role in keeping the blood less viscous, which in turn prevents a stroke.
Can Drinking Water Lower Your Blood Pressure?
Keeping well hydrated by drinking six to eight glasses of water daily (even more if working in hot and humid conditions) is beneficial for the blood pressure. High blood pressure (BP) or hypertension is a condition caused by the persistent high pressure of blood against the walls of arteries. It is also called systolic pressure (constantly greater than 139 mmHg) or diastolic pressure (constantly more than 89 mmHg).
Can You Get Rid of a UTI By Drinking Water?
UTI stands for urinary tract infection and it describes when your urinary system gets infected. While the effects of drinking water to flush out or get rid of UTIs is not proven, there has been a link between drinking over 2.2 liters of water daily and a decreased risk for UTIs.
Drinks Quiz
Drink to your health! Take the Drinks & Beverages Quiz to learn how your favorite drinks can impact your life, your behavior, and your waistline!
How Much Water Should You Drink Based on Your Weight?
Generally, you should aim to drink about 64 ounces of water per day. Check out the center below for more medical references on nutrition, including multimedia (slideshows, images, and quizzes), related disease conditions, treatment and diagnosis, medications, and prevention or wellness.
Is Drinking a Lot of Water Good for Your Prostate?
Doctors recommend drinking six to eight glasses of water (or 1.5 to 2 liters) daily. For prostate problems, limit water intake before going to bed at night. This will keep you from waking up at night to urinate repeatedly.
Is Drinking Distilled Water Good or Bad for You?
Distilled water is considered the purest form of water. There are both potential risks and benefits of drinking distilled water.
Nutritional Health: 10 Ways You’re Drinking Water Wrong
Your body is mostly made of water and needs it to work the right way. Avoid these myths and pitfalls.
The Best Times to Drink Water
Benefits of drinking water: general hydration, as an aid in brain function, to promote weight loss, to replace sweat loss after exercise, when you’re sick, and more.
What Happens to Your Body When You Drink Enough Water?
You might be surprised at how well your body works when you drink enough water. Find out exactly what can go right when you get your H2O.
What Is the Best Drink to Flush Your System?
Detox diets claim that they remove “toxins” from the body and improve your overall health. Some of the top drinks that claim to flush your system and detox your body include lemon detox drinks, mint and cucumber detox drinks, coconut water detox drinks and chia seed and aloe vera detox drinks.
What Is the Healthiest Water to Drink?
Mineral water and alkaline water may be some of the healthiest types of water because they provide your body with essential nutrients
Water Safety: What's Inside Your Drinking Water?`
What are the benefits of drinking water? How do you keep your drinking water safe and healthy? Learn about the water you drink and possible contaminants like giardia, cryptosporidium, lead, chlorine, and more. Discover how to boil your water in an emergency, and why fluoride in tap water is healthy for teeth.
Why Is Drinking Water In The Morning So Important?
Your body is 70% water, so it isn't surprising that you need to drink water every single day to maintain a healthy body. Drinking water in the morning is important because it helps your body recover from its nightly dehydration.
Will Drinking More Water Help With Edema?
Edema is the technical term for swelling, and it happens when fluid collects under the skin. Drinking water may help if you have mild edema.